Environmental consultancy for planning & development0330 236 7329hello@acp-consultants.com

Bat survey advice · Understand your next step

Bat surveys recommended? Design options and what happens next

A recommendation for further bat surveys should come with an explanation. Understand the findings, discuss your design options and agree the evidence your project needs.

ACP helps homeowners, architects and developers connect ecological advice with practical project decisions. We review what the report means for your proposed works and explore opportunities to avoid impacts.

This guide concerns development in England. The outcome depends on the site, the evidence and the complete proposal.

Discuss your report and plans See the possible next steps

Discuss your next step

Share your report and plans

Tell us what the assessment recommends and what you want to build.

Where is the site, and how far has the proposal progressed?

We use these details to respond to your enquiry. Please see our privacy policy. Sending an enquiry does not instruct us to begin work.

What does a recommendation for bat surveys mean?

Start by identifying which assessment you have and which question remains unanswered. A recommendation should relate to the proposed development, not simply the name of a survey package.

After a PEA

A Preliminary Ecological Appraisal considers the site’s wider ecological context and potential constraints. It may identify a need for more detailed bat assessment. Check whether the recommendation is for a building inspection, emergence surveys or work concerning trees and habitats.

Do not assume that a general reference to “bat surveys” already defines the fieldwork, scope or fee. Ask which findings and proposed activities led to it. Source 1

After a PRA

A Preliminary Roost Assessment examines a structure for bat evidence and features that could support roosting. The report should explain the findings, access limitations and implications for the works.

It may leave a question about presence, roost use or likely effects that further surveys need to answer. Potential suitability and a confirmed roost are different findings. Read the evidence and limitations together.

The advice you can expect from ACP

We help you understand the report and relate it to the project you want to build. If a recommendation is unclear, we explain the evidence behind it and what it means for the next decision.

We also raise practical opportunities to avoid impacts. This may involve discussing changes with your architect, reviewing how an extension connects to a building or checking which activities genuinely need to affect a feature.

We cannot promise a particular outcome before reviewing the evidence. However, you can expect an explanation of realistic options, remaining uncertainties and the reasons for any further work.

Our quotation identifies the agreed services. Where additional design coordination, report updates or planning liaison would help, we explain the scope and fee before you commit.

Four possible outcomes after reviewing the report and plans

These are possible conclusions of a competent review. They are not routes a client can select simply by preference or price.

1. The existing assessment is sufficient

The available evidence may support a clear conclusion for the particular works. The ecologist should record the reasoning, the drawings assessed and any limitations or measures relied upon.

This conclusion applies to that proposal. A later change to the works may require another review.

2. A revised design changes the assessment

An alternative may avoid an impact identified in the original scheme. The ecologist checks the revised drawings and whether the existing evidence is enough to support that conclusion.

Sometimes this changes or removes particular further survey requirements. Sometimes more evidence is still necessary. Source 2

3. Further survey evidence is needed

The review may identify an unresolved question about bats, roost use or the effects of the works. Further surveys can then be scoped to answer that question.

The quotation should explain the methods, coverage, reporting and any seasonal constraints.

4. Effects require a mitigation strategy

Where impacts remain, the project may need further design coordination, protective measures and licensing advice. The response depends on the evidence and the proposed activities.

Our bat mitigation licence service explains the separate licensing stage.

Could changing the design avoid impacts on bats?

Early review gives the team room to consider alternatives while the design is still flexible. Natural England’s standing advice supports avoiding harmful effects through the proposal’s design. Source 3

Conceptual cottage extension comparison: a roof-connected proposal beside a lower alternative retaining the main eaves
Illustrative design options: a roof-connected proposal and a lower alternative retaining the main eaves. Both require ecological and design assessment; this is not an approved scheme or an ACP project outcome. © ACP Consultants.

Review the junction, not just the footprint

This illustration compares a roof-connected extension with a lower alternative that retains the main eaves. It shows how a design discussion might start.

The alternative still needs assessment. The wall connection, construction access and new lighting may raise questions even when the main roof stays in place.

It is a conceptual comparison, not an approved scheme or a record of an ACP project. An architect must also assess feasibility and the wider design requirements.

Design questions worth discussing early

The examples below are prompts for the ecologist and designer. Their relevance depends on the building, evidence and works.

Retain the relevant feature

Could the proposal retain the structure, roof area or feature identified in the assessment? Check its access and supporting surroundings as well as the feature itself.

Change the connection or layout

Could a different junction, position or extent of works avoid the area of concern? Revised elevations and sections help test what would actually change.

Review lighting and access

Could lighting positions or construction arrangements change to address an identified effect? Consider how the completed scheme will operate as well as the building phase.

Why keeping the roof does not answer every question

A proposal can affect bats without removing roof tiles. The review needs to consider direct changes and effects arising around the retained feature.

Construction activities

Noise, vibration, temporary lighting and equipment may affect a roost or its access. Scaffolding and protective coverings also need consideration where they could obstruct relevant features.

The construction method can therefore matter as much as the final drawing. Raise uncertainties before the contractor starts.

The completed development

Changes to light, ventilation, temperature or access may alter a retained roost. Adjacent habitat and routes used by bats can also be relevant.

The assessment must consider how the building and surrounding space will function after completion. Source 2

When are further bat surveys still necessary?

Design review and survey work can inform each other. If the existing information cannot establish whether an alternative would avoid impacts, further evidence may be the proportionate next step.

For example, knowing where bats enter a building may be necessary to assess a proposed junction or access arrangement. A design that appears separate on a floor plan may still affect a relevant feature.

We explain what the recommended work is intended to establish. Where building emergence evidence is needed, our bat emergence survey page explains the fieldwork and reporting.

The survey programme should follow the site’s needs and appropriate conditions. See the bat survey season guide for the distinction between assessment types.

An illustrative house-extension review

This hypothetical example shows the conversation. It is not a survey conclusion, quotation or reported ACP case study.

The initial recommendation

A report identifies potential roost features near the proposed roof connection. It recommends further investigation because the original works could affect them.

The client asks what the finding means for the extension and whether the design can respond.

The design discussion

The architect considers a lower connection away from the identified features. The team checks the revised drawings, construction access and lighting together.

The ecologist reviews which questions this resolves and which remain open.

The documented next step

If the available evidence supports the revised approach, the ecologist explains the conclusion and any measures required. If it does not, further work is recommended for a stated reason.

The outcome is a clear next action, rather than an assumed promise of no more surveys.

What to send for a useful review

A complete information pack makes it easier to relate the recommendation to your current proposal. If you have received a PRA, use the PRA next-actions checklist to allocate recommendations and record the response.

  • 1. The full reportInclude plans, photographs, appendices, survey dates and any stated limitations.
  • 2. Current drawingsSend the site plan, existing and proposed layouts, elevations and relevant sections.
  • 3. The actual worksDescribe roof, wall, demolition, lighting, tree and access work, including temporary arrangements.
  • 4. Planning correspondenceInclude the council’s request, relevant conditions and any consultee comments.
  • 5. Changes since assessmentExplain revised drawings, alterations on site and any new information.
  • 6. Your team and programmeIdentify the designer, any existing ecologist and intended planning or construction dates.

Already working with another ecologist?

Begin by asking the report’s author to explain the recommendation and whether design changes could affect it. They know the assessment’s scope and observations.

A clearly scoped second opinion

If you would like ACP to review the position, send the full report and current drawings. A useful review tests the reasoning and evidence rather than promising a cheaper conclusion.

It may support the original recommendation, identify a need for clarification or suggest an alternative for assessment.

Clear responsibility for the next step

Tell us whether another ecologist retains an ongoing role. Agree who will revise the report, advise the design team and communicate with the planning authority.

The report’s age alone does not settle its relevance. Our report validity guide explains other factors to consider.

What happens when the design changes?

Give the ecologist the revised drawings before relying on the previous conclusion. A short description such as “the roof is unchanged” may omit details that affect the assessment.

Where a recommendation changes, the written advice should explain the evidence and the revised proposal. Ask which drawing versions it covers and whether a report update or further submission is needed.

For a planning application, the authority decides whether the submitted information is adequate. Wildlife protection also remains relevant where works do not need planning permission. Source 3 Source 5

See our bat surveys and planning permission guide for the wider planning context.

Agree the scope, cost and timing of the next action

Understand what you are commissioning

A review discussion, a written assessment, new fieldwork and planning liaison are different tasks. Confirm which are included and what deliverable you will receive.

Our bat survey costs page explains starting fees, quotation inclusions and possible later work.

Keep the programme realistic

Design review can begin with the information available, but it cannot guarantee that seasonal fieldwork will be unnecessary. Raise the issue early while there is time to consider alternatives.

Agree who will provide the next information and when the ecologist can review it. BCT recommends early engagement and discussion of impact-avoidance options. Source 6

Questions after a bat survey recommendation

Does a PEA recommendation automatically mean emergence surveys?

No. Read the recommendation and its reasoning. The next step may be a more detailed building assessment or another type of bat work. The appropriate scope depends on the findings, proposed activities and information still needed.

Can design changes remove the need for further bat surveys?

Sometimes. An ecologist must assess whether the revised proposal avoids relevant impacts and whether the available evidence supports that conclusion. In other cases, further surveys are still needed to establish that the alternative would protect bats.

Do I need a survey if the main roof will stay?

Retaining the roof does not settle the question. Wall features, roost access, lighting, noise, vibration and other construction effects may still matter. The complete works need assessment against the evidence.

Can we discuss alternatives before booking the next surveys?

Yes. Send the report and current plans so we can discuss an appropriate review scope. An early conversation can clarify options, although it may also confirm that further evidence is needed before a design decision.

Will ACP review another consultant’s recommendation?

We can discuss a review scope using the complete report, appendices and current plans. The review may support the original advice, identify questions or suggest alternatives for assessment. Tell us if another ecologist remains responsible for the project.

Is finding no bats during an inspection enough to stop?

Not necessarily. The report’s methods, access limitations and assessment of relevant features matter. An ecologist must consider what the inspection can establish and whether the proposed works need additional evidence.

Can I change the design and proceed without updating the report?

Ask the ecologist to review the revised drawings first. The original assessment relates to the proposal it considered. A change may require updated advice, further evidence or a revised planning submission.

Does a bat box replace the need for surveys or a licence?

No. Adding a box does not establish that the proposal avoids impacts or satisfies applicable requirements. Any protective or compensatory measures need to relate to the evidence, the works and the relevant planning or licensing position.

Guidance behind this approach

Sources reviewed on 13 November 2026. The examples explain a decision process; they do not determine the outcome for an individual site.

  1. CIEEM: Guidelines for Preliminary Ecological Appraisal

    Purpose and limitations of preliminary appraisal and the identification of further assessment needs.

  2. BCT: fourth-edition survey guidelines

    Paragraphs 2.2.30–2.2.31 address design changes and further surveys; Table 2.1 identifies direct and indirect effects.

  3. Natural England: bats and planning decisions

    Standing advice for England on survey evidence, avoidance and assessment of development proposals.

  4. BCT: avoidance, mitigation and compensation

    Explains the hierarchy and the need to consider a retained roost’s function and surroundings.

  5. Natural England: bat protection and licences

    Protection of bats and roosts, survey advice and licensing considerations.

  6. BCT: advice for developers

    Early ecological involvement and discussion of impact avoidance, mitigation and the later project stages.

Understand your options before deciding the next step

Send your report, current plans and the question you need to resolve. We will discuss the appropriate review or survey scope.